Appeal an EHC needs assessment or plan
Appeal a refusal to assess or reassess
When the local authority decides not to agree to an Education, Health and Care Needs (EHC) assessment, this is often called a 'refusal to assess'.
Follow these steps if you want to appeal this decision.
If you have received a refusal to assess decision, it is important to know how the local authority must make its decision.
The local authority's decision must be based on a 'legal test'.
The 'legal test' for an EHC needs assessment is as follows:
- Children and Families Act 2014 (Section 36) (8):
- The local authority must secure an EHC needs assessment for the child or young person if, after having regard to any views expressed and evidence submitted under subsection (7), the authority is of the opinion that:
(a) the child or young person has or may have special educational needs, and
(b) it may be necessary for special educational provision to be made for the child or young person in accordance with an EHC plan
There is guidance in the SEND Code of Practice section 9.14 which helps the local authority to make their decision. This is guidance though, so advisory, not compulsory - it is not the legal test. Some of the guidance is about the evidence the local authority could look at:
- Is there evidence (usually paperwork) to show that the education provider has taken relevant and purposeful action to identify, assess and meet the special educational needs of the child or young person?
- If the evidence shows that this action has been taken, does it also show that the child or young person has not made expected progress?
To inform their decision the local authority should have taken into account a wide range of evidence, with particular attention to:
- Evidence of the child or young person’s academic attainment (or developmental milestones in younger children) and rate of progress
- Information about the nature, extent and context of the child or young person’s SEN
- Evidence of the action already being taken by the early years provider, school or post-16 institution to meet the child or young person’s SEN
- Evidence that where progress has been made, it has only been as the result of much additional intervention and support over and above that which is usually provided
- Evidence of the child or young person’s physical, emotional and social development and health needs, drawing on relevant evidence from clinicians and other health professionals and what has been done to meet these by other agencies
- Where a young person is aged over 18, the local authority must consider whether the young person requires additional time, in comparison to the majority of others of the same age who do not have special educational needs, to complete their education or training
The decision letter must refer to the 'legal test' and may also refer to the evidence the local authority has used to make its decision.
Look closely at the reasons for the decision. Is the local authority showing that it has used the legal test and relevant evidence to make the decision?
You may want to challenge the decision if:
- the local authority has not mentioned the legal test in their decision
- the local authority has not mentioned the evidence it has used to make the decision
- and/or has not used all the evidence to make the decision
- and/or has used old or irrelevant evidence
What to consider
Think about whether your child or young person meets the legal test:
- they have or may have SEN and it may be necessary for special educational provision to be made for them in accordance with an EHC plan
- my child or young person has not been making progress and is already getting a high level of SEN Support
- my child or young person has not been making progress and should be having more SEN Support. I have met with the education provider and asked for more help, but they haven't provided it
- my child or young person has not been making progress and is not getting all they could from SEN Support. I have not asked the education provider for more help
- you may want to work with the education provider to make sure the SEN Support plan is as good as it can be. You can make another request if you want to. You can still challenge the decision if you want to
- my child or young person is making progress and having their needs met by SEN Support- you may want to accept the decision and carry on working with the education provider to make sure the SEN Support plan is as good as it can be. You can make another request if you want to. You can still challenge the decision if you want to
You must contact Global Mediation within 2 months if you disagree with the council's decision to refuse an assessment.
Telephone: 0800 064 4488
Email: sen@globalmediation.co.uk
Find out more about mediation before an EHCP appeal.
For a refusal to carry out an initial EHC needs assessment, complete SEND35a.
Use the form that matches the decision in your letter.
- Give the child or young person’s details and the council’s decision date.
- Explain why the child or young person has or may have SEN.
- Explain why an EHC plan may be necessary and why assessment is needed.
- State whether you want a decision on the papers or an oral hearing.
- Give details of anyone acting as an advocate or representative.
You can type your name to sign. If you need more space, write “See separate sheet” and label each attachment with the relevant form section.
Send your completed form to send@justice.gov.uk.
You will need to attach:
- the decision letter
- the mediation certificate
- any evidence
Keep a copy of everything you send.
What happens next
Refusal-to-assess appeals are normally decided using written evidence, unless an oral hearing is requested and agreed. If the appeal succeeds, the council must carry out an EHC needs assessment. This does not mean an EHC plan will be issued.
After you have sent your appeal, use the page “After you send your SEND appeal” for registration, deadlines, evidence, hearings and decisions.